Customer Reviews

Rated 5 out of 5 based on 28 rated reviews.
  • Rick K.
    ...savings also came with great customer service and a small town feel.Read Full Review

    “Procter Insurance saved me money when I switched from one of the bigger companies. The price savings also came with great customer service and a small town feel.”

  • JD
    Incredible service at an incredible price!Read Full Review

    “My family and I have been using Procter Insurance for decades for all our home, auto, and life insurance needs. I have checked other agencies and websites, and Chris always finds us the lowest rates. Incredible service at an incredible price!”

  • He's fabulous!Read Full Review

    “Chris has always been amazing with getting us the best quotes for our insurance needs! He is so quick with responding to us and is great with updating policies and customizing it to what we need! He’s fabulous!”

  • TB
    They clearly are the best!Read Full Review

    “We have been using the Procter Insurance Agency for over 30 years. My daughters now use Chris and Bob as well. We receive personal one-on-one attention. Their knowledge of the ever changing industry and their knowledge and understanding our changing family needs are incredible.I would not trust anyone else. They clearly are the best!”

  • Emily Walsh
    Chris has made insurance an easy, worry free part of my life.Read Full Review

    “My parents have been working with Chris and Proctor Insurance for as long as I can remember. They were pleased with his work and customer service. When I was off their insurance plan and on my own, there was no doubt I was going to stick with Chris. Even when I added my husband to my plan and our prices went up, Chris worked to get us the best quote that fit our needs! I can’t imagine having anyone better to work with! Chris has made insurance an easy, worry free part of my life.

  • JE
    We highly recommend Chris for all your insurance needs.Read Full Review

    “Chris Procter has been our Insurance Agent for over 20 years and we can’t speak highly enough of our experience working with him. Chris goes above and beyond to help us find the right insurance at affordable rates for our family. We highly recommend Chris for all your insurance needs. Thanks Chris for being such a pleasure to work with!”

  • Leslie Berth South Milwaukee
    Everything online, no hassles, great rates, excellent coverage...Read Full Review

    “Chris and his team took care of my urgent needs in no time flat! Everything online, no hassles, great rates, excellent coverage … done and DONE! Thank You Team Procter!!!”

  • Annie Bartkowski Karabon, Oak Creek, Wisconsin
    We are always satisfied with prompt, friendly service at affordable rates.Read Full Review

    “Procter Insurance Agency handles insurance for both our business and personal needs. We are always satisfied with prompt, friendly service at affordable rates. Recently, when Chris was out of the office, I had the pleasure of working with another staff member. She was able to help me resolve my issue quickly, within the same day, just like I needed. It’s nice to know that there are other knowledgeable staff members to lean on in time of need. We would definitely recommend Procter Insurance Agency to anyone in need of business or personal insurance!

  • LL
    We have ALWAYS been given excellent service...Read Full Review

    “Our family has been with Procter Insurance for decades- We have ALWAYS been given excellent service, great rates for amount of coverage and support when you need them!”

  • Procter Insurance has always handled our insurance well.Read Full Review

    “Procter Insurance has always handled our insurance well, but also given us additional help when needed. Recently, my wife had a car accident, which was the other guy’s fault, and the other guy’s insurance paid easily enough. But Chris was very helpful to her, with advice about how to handle the whole thing. And that was very reassuring at a stressful time. And you don’t measure that in dollars and cents.”

  • Chris and his office staff have been very helpful, prompt and professional.Read Full Review

    “Chris and his office staff have been very helpful, prompt and professional. We are so happy we were referred to them. Saved us several hundred dollars.”

  • SD
    ...prompt service and fair pricesRead Full Review

    “ We have been with Chris for many years because of the prompt service and fair prices”

  • yelp
    ...very happy overall with the company.Read Full Review

    “I was referred to Procter Insurance Agency by my dad who has been a happy customer of Chris Procter for years. I have had coverage with Procter Insurance Agency since mid 2014, and have been very happy overall with the company. Chris is easily accessible and always ready to help. He responds personally and promptly to phone calls and emails, and resolved my only claim so far in a matter of days.”

  • I've saved so much by going through Proctor Insurance Agency.Read Full Review

    “I can’t speak highly enough about Proctor Insurance Agency and the help that Chris has given me over the years. After purchasing a new car, being removed from my parent’s insurance and moving a few times, I was a bit overwhelmed with all of the paperwork and hoops to jump through with my car insurance. Thankfully, I had Chris’ help and he handled everything so smoothly. He always finds me such great deals and I’ve saved so much by going through Proctor Insurance Agency. Thanks so much, Chris!”

  • Lois Schmitz Spaay South Milwaukee, Wisconsin
    I have been very impressed with the service and diligence of the agency...Read Full Review

    “Have to give a shout out to Chris Procter and Procter Insurance Agency. I have been very impressed with the service and diligence of the agency to assist me with bundling of my own insurance for car and rental, not to mention the help in adding my teen driver to the policy at an affordable rate. The icing on the cake was my oldest son’s recent inquiry of Chris to secure car insurance; he does not have a stellar driving record and Chris was able to help him get a policy that was less than a previous company!! Chris and his staff are always friendly and ready to help in any way possible. Thanks for making insurance shopping less painful 🙂

    Lois Spaay”